When I was a kid, my best friend and I would shoot short “movies” on a VHS camcorder, and they were always horror comedies. We were a bit young to be thinking in terms of genre though. Rather, we came up with “awesome” stories and put on our costumes and make-up, and I threw a whipped cream pie in her face (yes, literally). Instinctively, we just felt like scary and funny go together.
People often talk about genre like it’s a box. But I like to think of genre more like a universal language, and being fluent in that language allows you to play with it and bend it effectively. Even young kids can sense it, as my friend and I did.
When I was starting out as a screenwriter, I studied on my own. I didn’t go to film school, but I read many books on screenwriting, and I watched movies just to deconstruct them with my stopwatch and notebook. I’d later convert my furiously scribbled notes into spreadsheets to dissect structure, pacing, twists, and payoffs. Clear patterns emerged within specific genres.
Early on, I stuck to “the rules” hard and fast. As my writing developed further, I started to better understand that genre is a promise to the audience. When a reader picks up a thriller novel, they expect propulsion. When a viewer turns on a romantic movie, they expect emotional payoff. With fantasy, they expect world-building.
Completely breaking genre rules can be alienating—“Hey, you broke your promise!”—but clever blends can be smart. A novel like Pride and Prejudice and Zombies instantly tell us its hybrid nature from the title alone. In film, producer Jason Blum does something similar in the horror space, taking familiar stories or comedies and giving them a dark twist: Totally Killer is basically Back to the Future with murder, and Happy Death Day is Groundhog Day with a serial killer.
Personally, I find stories that blend and bend genre in more subtle and surprising ways to be the most electrifying of all, and those types of hybrids often make a story feel more real. Life is not strictly a comedy. Or a tragedy. Or a thriller. It could be all three of those things at the same time. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind has a sci-fi premise, but at its core, it’s a beautiful love story. I sobbed my way through the final scenes. Putting a love story inside a sci-fi story or thriller doesn’t dilute tension but raises the stakes. Life is a hybrid, and my favorite books and movies are too. That’s the angle I like to write from most of all.
The most interesting stories don’t disregard genre. Instead, they cleverly converse with it. That’s the approach I try to take in my own work: honoring the language of genres while creating unexpected ways to blend them and surprise the reader.
Hallie Shepherd is an author and storyteller working across fiction and film. Follow her on Instagram for glimpses of the world that inspire her work.